Take your kids to work night at Thirsty Fest

by brewgasm on August 31, 2010

UPDATE: Thirsty Fest is still on, though the Sexual Chocolate and the Kentucky Breakfast Stout have been drunk dry. Thanks, y’all, for reading (and ruining my day). Seriously, though, the word is they’ll be tapping some rare Oskar Blues kegs tonight. Check it.

OK, y’all. Thirsty Fest at The Thirsty Monk in Asheville may just be the most brilliant idea for a beer festival ever. Repeat after me: 36 interesting  and rare craft kegs, three unique and obscure casks. Every day this week from 4 p.m. til closing until the beer’s gone. Flights of four with tasting note cards.

We dragged the kids over there because I just couldn’t wait–plus, it’s part of my job, right? I need beer news for both Mountain Xpress and Local Edge Radio. It’s tough job, but hey. The kids took their books and ate a pizza (thank you Monk Pub for making a cheese za, even though it’s not on the menu).

Because the natives got restless pretty darn fast, we tried only one flight, which was just dandy because I immediately went for the high gravity brews, concentrating, as I often do, on the Imperials.

Here’s what I quaffed tonight:

Foothills Sexual Chocolate 2010: a 10 percent Russian Imperial Stout. Smooth and chocolaty and typically one of my favorites.

The Sex Choc is delicious, but it’s overshadowed by the Founders Kentucky Breakfast Stout: an 11.2 percent Imperial Stout. My brewgasm of the night. Holy hell. Huge coffee and chocolate flavors finishing with that fiery bourbon kick. I could bathe in the nectar.

Also amazing is the Olde Hickory Barrel-Aged Scottish Ale. An 8 percenter, aged in Old Weller barrels. Less than 100 gallons made of this beautifully balanced, perfectly flavored brew.

Least but not last, you must try the special Highland Brewing Sour Seven Sisters: our local brewers added some extra Lactobacillus (and other yeasties) to their new Belgian Dubbel, and voila: a fruity sour. Only two casks made of this baby.

So I’ll be back to the Monk Pub one of these nights (or two), cause I still need to taste the Duck Rabbit Barrel-Aged Milk Stout, the Brewdog Hardcore IPA, the Rogue 21, the Stone 14th Anniversary Emperial IPA, and the Sweetwater Dank Tank Magnum Imperial Pils–just to name a few.

See y’all there. Don’t drink it all before I can taste it. Thanks.

{ 1 comment }

More area Brews News

by brewgasm on August 29, 2010

Here’s more area Brews News for your delectation (some cross-posted and updated from my column at Mountain Xpress:

Craggie Distributing

So I talked to Craggie Brewing master brewer Bill Drew last week, and he told me they’ve been picked up by Tryon Distributing, which distributes all over the state of N.C. This is big news for this young brewery. Initially, they’ll just be sending out kegs, but they hope to start bottling in the next few months.

Drew also has brewed a wheat beer with apple wood branches from Hendersonville apple orchards, called Hendo Schwarzweis, for the North Carolina Apple Festival in Hendersonville on Sept. 3 – 6. It’s a 3.7 percent ABV session beer–dark in color but light and slightly sweet. Interesting flavor, for sure. That beer will be available around the area and at Lexington Avenue Arts Fun Festival on Sept. 5 as well.

Blind Eye Beer Battle

Pack’s Tavern and Bruisin’ Ales beer shop hosted the Blind Eye Beer Battle on Thursday, Aug. 26, in the upstairs area at Pack’s. I popped by for a bit–tasted some yummy lamb kabobs and actually ate a couple of sweet breads (thymus glands–eeeekkkk). I also tasted a few of the porters–my favorite beer style. Mostly, I took photos and watched. Seemed like folks were having fun and finding a blind tasting to be more difficult than anticipated. This will be the first in a series of educational blind beer tastings that will be co-hosted by these two businesses.

The highest-rated beers, from Bruisin’ Ales blog were:

The highest-rated IPAs: 1) Sweetwater IPA 2) Terrapin Hopsecutioner 3) Bell’s Two Hearted Ale
The highest-rated porters: 1) Smuttynose Robust Porter 2) Founder’s Porter 3) Highland Oatmeal Porter

Brews Cruise expands to Oregon
Brews Cruise owners Mark and Trish Lyons have licensed the Asheville Brews Cruise brewery tour brand to Joel Bender, former guest services manager for the Grove Park Inn. The Lyons, who also set up a Brews Cruise licensee in Denver, will expand their business to Bend, Ore. The couple will relocate there in mid-September. Asheville Brews Cruise tours will continue as scheduled. Check the website for information. The Lyons will still help organize Asheville’s annual Winter Warmer Beer Festival, slated to take place on January 22, 2011.

Oktoberfest already?
Oktoberfest beers seem to get released earlier and earlier each year, which is fine by me, as they’re among my favorites.

Beating the other local breweries to the punch, Lexington Avenue Brewery has already released their Oktoberfest Marzen beer. Speaking of punch, it comes in at seven-percent alcohol per volume, and is available on tap at their brewpub at 39 N. Lexington Ave.

Highland Brewing Company releases their latest mountain-monikered seasonal, Clawhammer Oktoberfest, around September 1. It’s a full-bodied Marzen made with, of course, all German hops, that comes in at five-percent alcohol by volume. It’ll be available on tap and in 12-ounce bottles throughout the region.

Pisgah Brewing Company’s Oktoberfest beer is in the fermenter and should be on draught in their Taproom and around town by the end of September. The Pisgah folks say it was the Southeast’s first organic lager and leans toward authentic German domestic versions of this seasonal.

French Broad Brewery‘s Zepptemberfest, a Marzen brewed with a Kolsch yeast, is out and around town.

Green Man Brewing also is putting out an Oktoberfest brew. Check out their rocking new website as well.

Oktoberfest beers are typically lagers, which means they take longer to brew than ales. But look for French Broad’s take on the style regionally on tap and in 22-ouncers by the end of September as well.

At Craggie Brewing Company, Drew is test batching a mix of the Doppelbock and the Toubab Brewe (a Bavarian-Style Zwickel) beers to make an Oktoberfest brew.

If you’d like to try many of these Oktoberfest-y beers and more, plan to attend the second Annual Asheville Oktoberfest. Located on Wall Street downtown (kind of like a bier garten), it’s organized by the Asheville Downtown Association and will run from noon till 6 p.m.

Thank you for the lagers, y’all.

More on the Moog
Asheville Brewing Company’s Moog Filtered Ale was featured in a write-up in Wired Magazine this month. Wired loves the geeky science aspect of this beer, brewed to benefit Asheville’s Bob Moog Foundation and released on the anniversary of what would have been the world-famous inventor’s 76th birthday (May 27). Alas, the brew has sold out, but Asheville Brewing’s Mike Rangel says they’ll roll the filtered pale ale back out during MoogFest, on Oct. 29 – 31.

It’ll be on sale at the Asheville Civic Center and the Orange Peel throughout that weekend’s musical extravaganza. Rangel says proceeds from the sale of the beer to the Foundation total more than $5,000 so far. He expects the final donation to be $7,000 or $8,000.

{ 0 comments }

The winning beer name is…

by brewgasm on August 24, 2010

Stuntman Brown Ale!

Four weeks ago, we (Mountain Xpress and I) asked you to help Asheville Brewing Company rename their Brown Ale, once called simply Scottish Ale, and then referred to as Boogie Down Brown. More than 100 of you submitted close to 300 creative and brew-inspired names (see most below).

After much deliberation and debate (or so I hear), the owners at ABC decided that the new beer will be christened Stuntman Brown Ale. Congrats to Millie Bryant for submitting the winning name. She will receive, not just the glory of naming a local beer, but two tickets to the Brewgrass Festival on Sept. 18, $100 worth of gift cards to Asheville Brewing Company, and other beer-related swag. The other top two finalists were Outlaw Ale by Sean McNeal and Beer City Brown by Geoff Hughes (turned out that Outlaw has already been registered by another brewery).Thanks to all of you who participated.

Go forth and quaff some delicious Stuntman Brown Ale on draught at both Asheville Brewing Company locales.

Here’s a shot I took at Asheville Brewing last week for the Asheville Honest Pint Project. That’s a full 16-ounce pint glass, for sure.


{ 0 comments }

The Thirsty Monk in downtown Asheville is throwing what may be one of the more interesting beer events of the year–Thirsty Fest–starting next Monday, Aug. 30.

From owner Barry Bialik:

We’ve been holding back and collecting some of our extra rare, obscure and unique kegs (This says a lot considering our normal tap line) to release all in the same week. We’ve got more than 30 specialty kegs to tap and three casks including a soured Highland Seven Sisters, Stillwater Saison, & Oskar Blues Spiced Mama’s Little Yella. Some of the kegs include: Allagash Blonde, Ballast Point Bourbon Barrel Aged Black Marlin Porter, Foothills Sexual Chocolate, FOUNDERS KENTUCKY BOURBON STOUT, Rogue 21, Stone 14th Anniversary and so so many more. We’re going to have special Flights of Four so people can get to taste lots.

I’ll have the draught list for you soon. It’s a good thing they have those couches downstairs at the Monk. Guess where I’ll be sleeping next week?

UPDATE: Draught list showed up in my in-box just after I published this. Read it and drool.

Begins Monday August 30th at 4:00 p.m.
It’s over when the kegs are gone.
(BB stands for bourbon barrel)

1. Oskar Blues Whiskey mama (BB aged Mama) (tapped 9/1)
2. Oskar Blues Spiced Mama ( Cask) (tapped 9/1)
3. Oskar blues Old Double Baggard  (tapped 9/1)
4. Oskar Blues Ten Fidy 2009
5. Terrapin/ De Proef Monstre Rouge
6. Terrapin/ Bison Brewing Reunion 2010
7. Terrapin Boom Shaka Lager
8. Terrapin Hopzilla
9. Allagash Blonde
10. Ballast point BB Black Marlin Porter
11. The Bruery 7 Grain Saison
12. The Bruery Coton
13. Foothills BB Stout
14. Dogfish head Sah’tea
15. Founders KBS
16. Highland XV
17. Highland Aged Sour Seven Sisters (cask) (tapped 8/30)
18. Hitachino Nest Ancient Nipponia
19. Klokke Roeland
20. Del Ducato Sally Brown
21. Del Ducato Nuova Mattina
22. Mother Earth BB Belgian Tripel
23. Pisgah Fresh Hop
24. Moylan IPA
25. Stone saison du Buff
26. Stone 14 Anniversary
27. Foothills sexual Chocolate 2010
28. sweetwater Dank Tank magnum IP
29. Troubadour magma
30. Flying Dog imperial Chocolate Stout
31. Duck Rabbit Barrel aged Milk Stout
32. Olde Hickory Barrel aged Scottish ale
33. Olde Hickory  bardstone barley wine
34. Stillwater cellar door (cask) (tapped 8/2)
35. stillwater stateside saison   (tapped 8/2)
36. Rogue Old crustacean 2006
37. Rogue 21
38. Alvinne The Oak Bolleville
39. New Belgium Imperial Berliner Weisse

{ 1 comment }

Asheville Honest Pint Project

by brewgasm on August 19, 2010

Here’s the scoop, y’all. Or some of the scoop. It’s really a math story about ounces and cents and beer pours.

{ 4 comments }

Brews News podcast, beer bloggers con, plus

by brewgasm on August 19, 2010

Hey beer lovers,

Here’s the podcast from yesterday’s Brews News discussion on Local Edge Radio. We talked Beers & Baseball, Brews Cruise, Oktoberfest, Blind Eye Beer Tasting, and cherry tomatoes.

Also, comments are closed on the Beer Naming Contest for Asheville Brewing Company (below). We’ll be announcing the winner (I hope) next Tuesday here, on Mountain Xpress, on ABC’s Facebook page, on Twitter and on Local Edge Radio. It’ll be a beer naming media extravaganza.

In case you missed it–one of the slightly obscene photos from Baseball & Beer that were posted on the daily newspaper’s Web site. That’s my buddy Steve “The Heat” from Highland Brewing and James from Mountain Xpress. I was sober. Pinkie swear.

Also, I’m psyched to be going to the first ever Beer Bloggers Conference in Boulder, Colo., in November. The conference organizers have asked folks to vote for which city the con should be held in next year. Asheville is on the list. While I, personally, really want to go visit our nemesis city of Portland, Ore., I think it’d be another feather in Beer City, USA’s cap to host this conference.

So, if you’d like to support that cause, go vote here. And thanks to those of you who voted after I tweeted about it–holy hell, Asheville went from 6 to 77 votes in a matter of hours. We were in second place for a while (after Philadelphia) but someone’s since rallied San Francisco, so we’re currently in the third slot. So vote!

{ 2 comments }

UPDATE: You have until midnight tonight (Aug. 15) to put your beer names in the hat. Go get ‘em, beer lovers.

Here’s your chance to claim the glory of naming an Asheville brew.

For years, Asheville Brewing Company’s excellent brown ale has been called simply Scottish Ale. But company president Mike Rangel says he prefers kooky brew names, plus the term Scottish describes the style (after all, this is the brewery that’s given us the brew handles Shiva, Ninja and Rocket Girl). About a year ago, Rangel and crew renamed the Scottish as Boogie Down Brown. But that moniker just doesn’t roll off the tongue.

Here’s where you come in. Send us your name suggestions for this mildly sweet, mellowly hopped sessions beer, and you could win two tickets to the Brewgrass Beer Festival (September 18), $100 worth of gift cards to Asheville Brewing Company, and some other beer-related swag (perhaps even a Brewgasm T-shirt).

To submit a brew name (or several), simply add your creative sparkly ideas in the comments section below with a proper email address (I will not share your email address with anyone). You also can visit Asheville Brewing’s facebook page and add your ideas to the “Beer Naming Contest” thread there.

A couple caveats: the name can’t already be taken by another beer (the ABC folks will have to check that the winning name is available). And while we encourage sexy, punny, edgy monikers, the name can’t be vulgar, sexist, racist or otherwise inappropriate.

The deadline for submissions is Sunday, August 15, at midnight. We’ll announce the winner on Wednesday, August 25.

Now go put on your most creative beer hat and send us those handles! Yay beer!

{ 126 comments }

Beer snob? Check. Beer Fest snob? Check.

by brewgasm on August 11, 2010

I’ve already established that I’m a craft beer snob.

If you need further proof, you can read this week’s Brews News column, which features a number of local releases and information about upcoming regional beer festivals.

But let me clarify, briefly:

My part-time job: Beer news columnist for Mountain Xpress alternative newsweekly.

My job description (as far as I can tell): Local craft beer cheerleader. Beer news chaser. Photographer of people drinking beer, loving beer, and acting up with craft beer.

This blog: The scoop on beers I like and don’t like–whether they be local, regional, or national. My personal take on beer festivals, beer education, and more. My intimate brewgasms. And links to my part-time paid work, in case you’re interested, and to help drive traffic to Mountain Xpress.

Got it?

Good.

If you want, you can go check out some of the photos I took at last Saturday’s Baseball & Beers Festival here in Asheville on Mountain Xpress’ blog.

There are slightly obscene photos of me vamping with this man-sized Gaelic Ale here.

And now I’ll tell you what I really thought about this festival.

It was pretty lame.

I didn’t attend the inaugural Baseball & Beers last year, but I hear that it attracted more of a crowd than this year’s fest. This one seemed sparse. I’m not sure if that’s because there wasn’t lots of advance advertising or because it’s a time of year when lots of folks are on vacation — or a bit of both.

I  think this Festival has the potential to draw more beer lovers and be a fun event. The music was pretty good (though I only really listened to Soulgrass Rebellion, who are cute in a scruffy, growly kind of way). And I hear the food, provided by Wild Wings and integrating local beers into the cooking was good (i.e., wings with hot sauce spiked with local beer).

Soulgrass Rebellion doing their thang.

But not all the local and regional breweries were represented. Even though one of the beneficiaries of the event was the Asheville Brewers Alliance, not all members of the ABA were pouring their beers. And the non-local beers were poured by volunteers and distributors, not by brewers.

Distributors are great because they bring us beers that we might not get to try otherwise from faraway places like the magical state of Oregon. But at a beer fest, I want to talk to brewers or, at least, to people who know and understand craft beer.

And folks, Anheuser-Busch products don’t count as craft beers. Period. Step away from the fricking Shock Top. If you advertise an event as a “craft” festival, stick with true craft beers.

Finally, I found the layout to be disjointed. It was a longish walk between the two areas of action, and one of the music stages was set up in the bullpen. People seemed to feel weird about walking down into the bullpen, so the musicians there were kind of stranded in no man’s land, playing to, well, dirt.

If there’s not going to be baseball at Baseball & Beers, at least put the fest out on McCormick field. I think field repairs would be minimum, especially if the fest was moved to a time of year when the Tourists aren’t playing (early spring seems open for a local beer fest). Get organized farther in advance, so you can pull in all the regional breweries and, perhaps, more Southeastern breweries, who might not be on your distributor’s catalog, but who would like a chance to promote their brews.

The highlight of the Fest, as far as I could tell, was the giant Jenga-type game that Asheville Brewing Company President Mike Rangel brought for festival-goers to play.

Giant Jenga rocked.

Asheville is Beer City, USA. Let’s rise to the challenge and make every craft beer event great, y’all.

Prosit.

{ 7 comments }

WNC area Brews News and more

by brewgasm on August 4, 2010

Here’s some more Brews News from my biweekly Mountain Xpress column.  More is on the way next week.

Trying to catch up as vacation has put me a bit behind the ball in terms of keeping up with just about everything. Sorry bout that.

I’m also cutting back on my daily beer consumption in order to prepare for fall beer festival season. Which is difficult given all the amazing new releases by local breweries.

Can you say Pisgah Brewing Red Devil Ale? Possibly my favorite local beer — a nine percent Belgian brewed with tart cherries and raspberries. Only 20-barrels brewed once a year — so it’ll be just a memory in about a month. In the mean time, find it at Pisgah’s Taproom and around town. Nine Mile Restaurant had a good supply of the nectar last year.

If you prefer to listen to your news, here’s me talking local beer releases, festivals and more on Local Edge Radio yesterday–starts about half way through the podcast. Also, listen to Chad Oliphant of Smiling Hara Tempeh chat about soy and local food.

One more photo from Mother Earth Brewing, of their pre-printed laminated flight cards with extensive beer descriptions. Love these. Ahem, Asheville brewers.

{ 0 comments }

In the steamy flatlands of the so-called Inner Banks of North Carolina, there’s a small oasis called Kinston. It’s a town that grew out of the tobacco fields surrounding it.

As those fields have shrunk thus has the town, whose population has steadily but slowly decreased since the middle of the last century. Yes, tobacco’s been toppled from its throne and the manufacturing and textile plants that sustained so many Southern towns have relocated to overseas climes.

Even so, some Kinston-area folks still have capital and the wherewithal to use it. They want to remake the town and so are creating surprising pockets of sophisticated revitalization among the half-full brick storefronts.

Me and head brewer at Mother Earth Brewing. That’s my look of joy and amazement.

I made the trek to Kinston last week to visit the 10-month-old craft brewery called, without irony, Mother Earth Brewing.

MEB is the brainchild, business, and brewing Mecca of two lifelong Kinston residents, Stephen Hill and his son-in-law, Trent Mooring. The twosome’s smart enough to recognize a trend—the craft beer explosion—and take a no-holds-barred leap. They’re also wise enough to do it in an area where no one else has taken the brewing plunge. In the process, MEB can parch the thirst of a part of the state where the asphalt shimmers with light-distorting waves for at least half the year.

I’ve spent a lot of time in breweries, and MEB is a Mercedes brewery. Unlike most small start-up craft breweries, the MEBers jumped right into bottling and distribution—which, given their locale, makes sense. They also had to start off right by making that most significant of decisions–the head brewer hire.

And by gosh, hiring Chicago-native, big beer aficionado and charming guy Josh Brewer may have been the owners’ best move. In fact, Mooring told me it was about the smartest thing he’s done in so far in this business.

Yes, in one of those lovely cases of predestination, Brewer truly is his surname.

Josh Brewer, brewer

So you’ve renovated an old building (according to Mooring, it once housed the first drive-through pharmacy in N.C.). You’ve brought high-end brewing equipment. You’ve hired your brewer and let him put together his team (Greg, Pete and Travis). So, it’s time to put the mash in the tanks and brew the damn beer. I probably don’t have to tell you that all these ingredients can be perfectly rendered, but if the product’s not amazing? Well, then you’ve got a couple tons of pricey stainless steel on your hands and some smart folks out of work.

As I’ve noted before, you can’t sell craft beer in this state unless it’s great craft beer. While I’ll try any beer once, I only go back to those that are excellent. And Brewer’s are that.

In fact, I decided to make the trek to MEB based on a mere sip of Brewer’s Four Roses Bourbon barrel-aged Tripel Overhead Belgian at Asheville’s Beer City Festival in June. One taste of that nectar was all the impetus necessary to get my heiney road-tripping.

Brick, stainless steel and beer heaven

Even so, I was surprised—both by the forethought put into Mother Earth’s brewery and the quality and creativity of the beers.

Brewer’s standard palette (so far) includes Sisters of the Moon IPA, Weeping Willow Wit, Endless River Kolsch, and Dark Cloud Dunkel Lager. All of which are solid, great-tasting craft beers.

But what I love, and what struck me as his really strong suit, are Brewer’s “experimental” brews. May I wax rhapsodic for a few lines about some of these beers? Two words: lemon lager. While they’re the norm in the big domestic beer world, lagers are rarer in the craft beer universe. They’re typically not big flavorful beers, and they take longer to ferment than ales. But when they’re done right and well, they’re amazing. Brewer’s lemon lager is one of these—light, easy-to-drink, perfectly carbonated, with just a touch of lemon tang. I think my slightly out-of-proportion enthusiasm for this brew surprised Brewer. But yes…I love that lager.

Enlivening the other end of the beer spectrum is MEB’s barrel-aged Imperial Stout. I’m a stout junkie, and this one rocks. It’s a smooth chocolate-rich dark brew with a bourbon bite finish and a creamy head that’ll make you want to lick your lips (or someone else’s).

Sadly, these “experimental” beers are only on draught–some only at the brewery—though I hear that a few might be bottled as seasonal specials. Please make it so.

As I mentioned earlier , the MEB team decided to put a good bit of their capital straight into bottling and distribution, which given their location, makes sense. But what’s remarkable to me is how quickly they’ve grown. Mooring says they now have about 550 accounts throughout the state — at least 25 of those in Beer City, USA (Asheville). They’ve doubled their capacityin the past month, adding a couple 60-barrel fermenters that shoot up into the space where most of the building’s second floor once resided.

Josh and me in MEB conference room, looking down on the tanks (well, I’m talking). But wow.

That’s pretty phenomenal growth, even with Tryon Distributing on your side. And those accounts are only in the Tarheel state. Next up for MEB is a possible excursion into the Atlanta area. Like Asheville, Atlanta’s got some great breweries, but there’s lots of room for craft beer growth there.

Back to Mother Earth.  The brewery’s adjoining taproom also is rather unexpected—think LA meets Deep South. And I’m not talking Lower Alabama. Wall-high white curtains kiss the rough-hewn floor planks. Black leather sofas mix with modern-retro floor lamps and red pod chairs inviting decadence. A simple and elegant central four-sided bar offers either small group tête-à-têtes or surreptitious people watching. The bar top’s lit from within by blue LEDs. Not exactly the best lighting for me personally, but an interesting touch.

MEB’s taproom. Brewer pours.

Another way that MEB is making their mark is more subtle, but important in today’s marketing world. This would be their “green” emphasis (solar panels, green building materials, use of locally grown products when possible, etc.). And their feminine logo, labeling and packaging complements that Gaia theme. Their labels are locally-inspired landscape paintings by Mooring’s high school art teacher.

Mother Earth Brewing is hometown equals femme power equals amazing beer equals let’s quaff to save the world. I kind of fell in love. With everything except the blue LEDs.

As y’all know, one of my beer-writing goals is to help educate the more beautiful half of the beer-drinking world about my favorite beverage. And, despite being mostly run by guys (albeit cute ones), MEB clearly understands that seducing half the population to quaff their product is indeed half the battle. And I appreciate that.

So, if you’re anywhere nearby, it’s worth making a trip to Kinston and Mother Earth (only about an hour and a half drive from Raleigh). And I haven’t even mentioned the amazing restaurant around the corner—Chef and The Farmer—owned and run by another Chicagoan and his locally-born spouse. Amazing food. And thanks to Josh Brewer, the restauranteurs know beer too.

This would be the best appetizer I’ve eaten in my life. It’s fresh sliced peaches wrapped in proscuitto and topped with sweet mustard and a spicy pecan puree. Chef and the Farmer Restaurant. Go eat there. Period.

My trip last week also included visits to Carolina Brewery in Chapel Hill and Big Boss Brewing in Raleigh. Those stories to follow.

Skaal, y’all. Peace, love & beer.

{ 7 comments }